Birbraer Adolf N.
Birbraer Adolf N.

Бирбраер Адольф Никитич Birbraer Adolf N.
Candidate of Science (Phd), Associate prof.


Publications

Probability of a High-Speed Military Aircraft Falling at a Nuclear Power Plant and Setting of Design Loads on Building Structures
Issue: #6 2020
read more

The article is devoted to issues related to the probabilistic justification of the safety of nuclear power plants (NPP) when a high-speed military aircraft falls. The random parameters are the recurrence of falls and the direction of the aircraft's trajectory. The conservative value of the recurrence of falls, given in the IAEA documents, was used, which ensures a high degree of NPP safety. The aircraft approach is assumed to be equally probable from either side. The trajectory slope is specified taking into account the IAEA documents and statistics of aviation accidents.

          The aircraft impact load is applied to one of the structures, therefore the impact probability must be determined independently for each of them. It is proportional to the equivalent area of the building structure, depending on its size, shape, position in space and in relation to other structures. Expressions are given for the equivalent areas of structures of various shapes, typical for NPP. It is shown that if the aircraft crash is unintentional (accident), then with the usual dimensions of structures, the probability of an impact in them is less than the value, starting from which, according to Russian standards, it must be taken into account in the design basis of the NPP, i.e. it can be ignored. Dependencies are given for calculating the probability of an aircraft strike in the case of a deliberately organized accident (terrorist attack), in which the aircraft will surely fall on the territory of “Nuclear Island” of the NPP.

          The procedure for setting the design loads on the building structures of a NPP in the case of a deliberate aircraft fall based on the allowed probability of their realization is described. It is shown that this method of setting the loads makes it possible to substantiate their significant reduction, which leads to a reduction in the cost of the NPP while guaranteeing its safety. A probabilistic assessment of structures safety of existing NPP in the event of an aircraft impact is discussed.

Probability of Falling Aircraft Trajectory Angle and Recurrence of Aircraft Falls
Issue:
read more

The article is devoted to the determination of the probability characteristics of the parameters that are necessary for the safety analysis of nuclear power plant (NPP) when airplane falls on it. Probability distribution (probability density and cumulative function) of an aircraft trajectory angle with the vertical was found via processing of the world statistics of aircraft accidents. Recurrence of aircraft falls within the bounds of standard area was obtained by means of analysis of aircraft accident protocols with airplanes of general aviation in the United States. These data can be used when designing of NPPs in Russia.

Probability of Accidental and Intentional Aircraft Fall on NPP Safety Related Structures
Issue:
read more

The article is devoted to determination of probability of aircraft fall on nuclear power plant (NPP). Probability distribution of aircraft trajectory angle based on aircraft accidents statistics is used. Equiprobable aircraft approach from any direction is supposed. Probability distribution of impact to a building structure under an arbitrary angle to its normal was determined. Probability of impact to building structures of various shapes (typical for NPPs) was calculated. An example of calculation of the aircraft fall probability on NPP is given. The procedure for determination of the impact probability to building structures at intentional aircraft crash (act of terrorism) was assumed.

Accounting of Random Factors in the Design of a NPP for an Aircraft Impact
Issue: #2-2022
read more

The article is devoted to taking into account random factors when an aircraft impact is included in the design basis of a nuclear power plant (NPP). The fall of transport and high-speed military aircrafts in cases of unintentional (emergency) and deliberately organized (terrorist act) crash is considered. It is shown that in case of an unintentional fall, the impact of an aircraft into structures of ordinary sizes can be ignored due to the too low probability. Two methods of probabilistic setting of design loads on building structures are proposed. A technique for probabilistic setting of floor response spectra (FRS) is proposed, by means of which dynamic loads on technological equipment are calculated. It is shown that the probabilistic approach can significantly reduce the design loads while maintaining the safety of NPP. The procedure for determining the coefficients of combinations for summing up of the same name internal forces, calculated by three components of the FRS, is de­scribed